OUR CONTACTS


PO Box 16122 Collins Street West Victoria 8007 Australia

(+23) 345 322 233

FIA Sales Leaders 2015 to 2025

HomeResearchFIA Sales Leaders 2015 to 2025
INDUSTRY ANALYSIS · FIXED INDEXED ANNUITIES · UPDATED JULY 2026

In 2015 Athene ranked sixth in fixed indexed annuity sales and Allianz ranked first. Eleven years later the order has flipped. This report walks through LIMRA carrier sales data for 2015 through 2025, 220 carrier-year records in all, and explains how private-equity-backed insurers rewrote the top of the rankings.

By Jason Caudill, MBA, My Annuity Store Research. Data through 2025, pulled May 23, 2026. Nineteen pages including a rank-movement heatmap, a five-point buyer checklist, an FAQ, methodology, and the full Top 20 table for every year.

THE MARKET IN FOUR NUMBERS
$
0
B
2025 INDUSTRY FIA SALES
$
0
B
CUMULATIVE SALES 2015 TO 2025
+
0
%
ELEVEN-YEAR GROWTH
$
0
B
ATHENE 2025 RECORD

Source: LIMRA U.S. Individual Annuity Sales releases, 2015 to 2025. Industry totals include carriers outside the Top 20.

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

HOW ATHENE DETHRONED ALLIANZ

The headline numbers look modest. U.S. industry FIA sales grew from $54.5 billion in 2015 to $127.9 billion in 2025, a 135% increase. One level down the picture changes. Athene’s annual FIA sales went from $2.4 billion to $15.0 billion, roughly six-fold, in a window where the market only doubled. Allianz held an $8.7 billion to $10.2 billion range for five years, fell to $5.0 billion in the pandemic-disrupted 2020 cycle, and has finished second every year since except 2023.

What happened in between is a story about who owns these companies. Apollo Global Management spent the better part of a decade rebuilding Athene’s balance sheet around alternative credit and used the resulting yield advantage to win FIA business one independent distribution channel at a time. By 2025, three of the top five FIA carriers were affiliated with private equity or alternative asset managers.

The Top 20 have held about 85% of the market for the entire decade. That concentration has been remarkably stable even as the cast at the top changed dramatically. The dip came in 2020, when sales fell to $55.5 billion. The surge came in 2024, when sales jumped 32% in a single year as the Fed’s rate cycle made FIA crediting competitive against bonds and CDs for the first time in over a decade.

THE RIVALRY

ATHENE VERSUS ALLIANZ, YEAR BY YEAR

From 2015 to 2019 Allianz Life was the undisputed leader. The flagship Allianz 222 was the best-selling FIA in America for years, and Allianz was first to market with volatility-controlled custom indices by roughly half a decade. Most of the index design and rider innovation the PE-backed carriers ship today has a recognizable Allianz lineage.

Athene climbed methodically, from sixth in 2015 to third in 2016 and second from 2017 through 2019, with the 2013 Aviva USA acquisition as the major break. The turning point was 2020. Face-to-face distribution shut down, but Apollo’s balance sheet kept generating spread income that Athene could pass through as competitive crediting. Athene overtook Allianz at $5.8 billion to $5.0 billion, cemented the lead in 2021, and crossed $10 billion in 2022. Allianz edged back ahead in 2023 by $342 million, then Athene retook first in 2024 and posted $15.0 billion in 2025 against $11.7 billion.

Year Industry YoY #1 carrier #1 sales
2015 $54.5B n/a Allianz Life $8.7B
2017 $57.6B -5.4% Allianz Life $7.5B
2019 $73.5B +5.6% Allianz Life $8.4B
2020 $55.5B -24.5% Athene $5.8B
2022 $79.8B +25.3% Athene $10.1B
2023 $95.9B +20.2% Allianz Life $11.1B
2024 $126.9B +32.3% Athene $13.6B
2025 $127.9B +0.8% Athene $15.0B

Selected years from Table 1 of the report. Source: LIMRA U.S. Individual Annuity Sales.

2025 RANKINGS

A SETTLED TOP FIVE AND A FLUID BOTTOM FIFTEEN

# Carrier 2025 sales Share vs 2024
1 Athene Annuity & Life $15.0B 11.7% +10.2%
2 Allianz Life of North America $11.7B 9.1% -9.0%
3 Corebridge Financial $10.0B 7.8% +8.5%
4 Sammons Financial Companies $9.5B 7.5% -21.4%
5 American Equity Investment Life $7.2B 5.6% -3.2%
6 Fidelity & Guaranty Life $6.7B 5.2% +1.4%
7 Nationwide $6.1B 4.8% -11.6%
8 Global Atlantic Financial Group $5.7B 4.5% -10.3%
9 Delaware Life $5.6B 4.4% +165.6%
10 Security Benefit Life $5.0B 3.9% +6.0%

Top 10 of 20. The full Top 20 for 2025, and for every year back to 2015, is in the PDF. Source: LIMRA.

Three of the 2025 top five (Athene under Apollo, Corebridge with Brookfield as majority owner, and American Equity under Brookfield) are affiliated with alternative-asset managers. Allianz and Sammons are the two large non-PE leaders. Athene also finished first in MYGA sales for 2025, the only carrier in the dataset to hold both titles in the same year. Carriers ranked 11 through 20 typically hold their spots by $200 million to $500 million, so one product launch or distribution deal can move a carrier three or four places.

FOR BUYERS

FIVE THINGS TO TAKE AWAY IF YOU ARE SHOPPING FOR AN FIA

1. VOLUME IS NOT A RECOMMENDATION

The right FIA is the one whose surrender period, crediting strategy, and income rider fit your situation, not the one with the biggest market share.

2. AN A RATING IS INCOMPLETE

All five 2025 leaders carry A or A+ from AM Best. The differences are in what backs the balance sheet: alternative credit at PE-backed carriers, investment-grade bonds at Allianz.

3. LOOK PAST HEADLINE CAPS

Ask your agent to model both contracts against actual historical index returns over a 5-to-10-year window instead of comparing cap rates alone.

4. KNOW WHO SERVICES YOU

Forethought is now Global Atlantic, AIG is now Corebridge, Great American is now MassMutual Ascend, American Equity is now Brookfield. Terms do not change but service does.

5. THE BOTTOM 15 IS FLUID

A newer PE-backed carrier is not automatically a bad one, but a short track record warrants extra due diligence on financial strength and reserve structure.

“THE FIA MARKET HAS BEEN RESHAPED BY PRIVATE EQUITY CAPITAL, NOT BY LEGACY MUTUALS.”

 

– From the report’s conclusion

METHODOLOGY

DATA AND SOURCES

All sales figures and rankings come from LIMRA U.S. Individual Annuity Sales releases for 2015 through 2025, which represent about 92% of U.S. annuity sales. Renamed carriers (AIG to Corebridge, Forethought into Global Atlantic, American Equity under Brookfield) are treated as continuations. LIMRA revises prior years as late reporters update, which can shift individual figures by 1 to 3%. Full dataset available on request at research@myannuitystore.com.

My Annuity Store does not accept paid placement, sponsored rankings, or carrier-funded research. This report is informational, not personalized financial, tax, or legal advice. Rankings are not endorsements of any contract. Guarantees are subject to the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurer.

  1. Laura Benitez, “Rowan Says People Lost Their Minds Over Private Credit Fears.” WealthManagement.com, November 25, 2025.
  2. Kerry Pechter, “A Revolt Against PE-Led Annuity Issuers.” Retirement Income Journal, December 9, 2021.
  3. National Association of Insurance Commissioners, “Insurance Topics: Private Equity.” Includes the 13 regulatory considerations adopted June 2022.
  4. Apollo Global Management, “Apollo History,” corporate timeline.
  5. Apollo Global Management, closing of Athene’s acquisition of Aviva USA, October 2013.
  6. Apollo Global Management, “Apollo Completes Merger with Athene,” January 3, 2022.
  7. American International Group, “AIG Announces Closing of Corebridge Financial, Inc. Initial Public Offering,” September 19, 2022.
  8. Brookfield Asset Management, “Brookfield Reinsurance to Acquire AEL in $4.3 Billion Transaction,” 2023 to 2024.
  9. MassMutual, “MassMutual to Acquire Great American Life Insurance Company,” January 27, 2021.
  10. LIMRA U.S. Individual Annuity Sales releases, 2015 to 2025.

The online version with interactive charts and every year’s full ranking table is on My Annuity Store.

READ THE FULL REPORT

Nineteen pages, four figures, the 2015 to 2025 heatmap, and the complete Top 20 for every year. Free, no email required.